Although he'd never experimented with penetration, after Devin's second shoot, I asked him if he'd be willing to go there, and he was... uhm... open to the idea. So, for his third shoot, that's where Devin and I ventured

I slid my hand under Jaxon's leg & began rubbing his hole

Drew's eyes rolled back in his head as my probing found his prostate and he all but had an anal orgasm

Hipster gets fucked for the first time, rough anal. The guy almost cries from a big dick Oliver Strelly Falcon Al - 95

Straight guy's prostate get pushed and his dick goes rock-hard

Straight-acting Rude Boy--will he let me Fuck Him

This straight guy can't get enough of my fingers probing his hole

I squeezed his cock tight & staved off full orgasm with some ejaculation but we kept going, and within seven minutes, Kannon was truly ready to blow

This straight dude's cock got rock-hard as I pushed the vibrator into his virgin hole

Amos' female partner sounds a bit sexually freaky (in a good way) and introduced Amos to the joys of male butt play

Straight dude's first blowjob & ass rimming from a guy

I decided to begin a new series that encompasses a particular favored model’s entire catalogue, and for some reason, Avery was the first who came to mind

For the second in the new CAUSA Classic CUMpilation series, our eyes turn toward Billy's big, bright blue eyes

Leeroy Jones may be more pro-am than amateur, but nowhere else other than the CAUSA massage table has his prostate been so stimulated that Leeroy sexperienced his first hands-free orgasm while having my finger up his butt

Next in the CAUSA Classic CUMpilation series, I decided to jump forward to 2008 when 19-year-old, active-duty AF Morgan slid onto the ClubAmateurUSA massage table

One year ago, TreyDaddie slid onto the CAUSA massage table, and to my surprise, he's back

And here he is... the most requested / inquired about CAUSA guy in ClubAmateurUSA's 18-year history, Kole

Tyler's back and rockin' my world as usual. With his Arizona-desert tan and a little facial hair, he' looking sexier than ever. WOOF

More fingers please

To celebrate ClubAmateurUSA's 750th exclusive, original video and also exclusive to CAUSA, the Emperor Gracen returns

Tariq's thick cock pulsed throughout the anal play with him on the edge of orgasm the entire time

A Hidden Camera for an Oil Massage! A Soccer Player with a Huge Cock Comes in and Gets Stroked...Without Knowing Anything! : See

Giving to my step father's step

The project continues and ASG 2.0 coming Online Now!! All of our AmateurStraightGuys Videos are coming back, restored and enhanced into HD, UHD, and 4K! and /channels/jaysstraightguys -Jay

Twink Brings Buddy To Older Friend Of Family For His First Anal Sex - Virgin No More Pt 2 - DisruptiveFilms

Polaroid Pounding

Boss's Wife Pegs Husband Employees - Dante Colle, McKenzie Lee - Biphoria

Seeing wife fuck another man makes him horny

I get a little hyped up in the hours leading to his next scheduled shoot, and this time was no exception. As a result, Soren's plump and tender balls and nutsack got the workout of their life

I knew when Shayne contacted me on my favorite sex and swingers site, that I was hell bent to capture him on video. He's young, hung, hella cute, and sexually curious. Uhm... PERFECT

So, CAUSA has a new Strawberry-Blonde cHunk in da house, and he's str8, married (to a woman), practicing LDS, and sexploring. Please welcome Eddie to the ClubAmateurUSA massage table

He's BAAAAaaaack! For the first time since December 2019, CAUSA's Elias returns to the table

From a member: "I'm really digging Rainer's dirty Amish look, and that he always keeps his body hair untouched is a bonus. His sexperience flows so organically when he crawls on the massage table

Braydyn's been working out, has let his hair grow out, & he's even more beautiful today than he was six years ago - if that's even possible. When I saw him flash his pearly whites, all I could do was GRRRWOOF and say, "Let's g

Ewan’s entire body was on sensory overload. It was one of the most erotic things to witness and actually participate in

ClubAmateurUSA 2022 CUMpilation part 3, featuring TreyDaddi, Royal, Gracen, Tariq, Soren, Elian and Eddie

Enjoy Gunner's return with a special appearance by the original Zaddy, Ken Mack

In this new vid with Soren, he has two orgasms and cumshots within 20 minutes of each other. But Soren made me work it for it

CAUSA newbie Quinlynn sooooo wasn't mentally prepared for the physical pleasure that he sexperienced

Straight. Married. Swinger. Handsome. Built. Endowed. Curious. Having just turned 53, Magnum checked all of the boxes for my ideal ClubAmateurUSA "Mature Man" poster boy

Casey recently reappeared on AFF, and as soon as I reviewed his most recent pix, I knew that I wanted to run his three videos as a CAUSA Classic CUMpilation